
Total is reached by multiplying each individual criterion [marked on a scale of 1-9] by its weight and then summing these scores.
Although Acme Supply seems to be the preferred supplier:
Would you agree with the criteria selected?Would you agree with the weighting given to each criterion?
Are you sure every available supplier was considered?
If you were a dissident member of the group which made this decision, would you be tempted to undermine it at a later date?